
CRITERION #01
Faith foundation documentation
FCI Framework criterion 01
Formally recognising faith values as the foundation of investment practice
Faith foundation documentation overview
CRITERION 01
Faith foundation documentation explains how an organisation’s faith tradition, theological principles, and teachings are set out within its investment policy and used to guide investment decision-making. It is the point at which beliefs and values are translated into practical investment guidance.
Where faith foundations are not clearly documented, investment policy becomes open to interpretation. Trustees and advisers may rely on general financial norms rather than faith-specific guidance. Over time this leads to inconsistent application of values and a widening gap between investment practice and organisational mission.
Clear documentation does the opposite: it provides continuity and clarity, helping ensure that investment decisions remain grounded in the organisation’s faith commitments even as leadership, staff, and advisory arrangements change.
This criterion sits at the very foundation of faith-consistent investing. Without clear faith documentation, the other elements of alignment – for example, negative screening, positive screening, stewardship, engagement, impact – risk becoming disconnected from their moral purpose and defaulting into purely technical investment processes.
Why strong faith foundation documentation matters
A clearly expressed faith foundation serves the organisation and everyone who advises or manages its assets:
-
Mandate clarity. It reduces the risk of misinterpretation and misalignment between an organisation’s expressed values and the strategies actually implemented on its behalf.
-
Consistent advice. It helps ensure exclusions, engagement priorities, and trade-offs are applied consistently over time and across portfolios.
-
Stronger adviser–client dialogue. Explicit faith foundations enable more constructive conversations about values, priorities, and constraints.
-
Faithful implementation. Advisers and managers are far better equipped to serve faith-based clients when theological intent is clearly documented rather than assumed.
Common gaps and weaknesses
-
Failure to articulate how faith informs investment decision-making
-
Using generic faith language without theological specificity
-
Failure to reference readily available denominational resources
-
Use of 'stewardship' as a managerial concept, disconnected from its religious meaning
-
Assumption that faith identity is self-evident, rather than requiring explanation
What our analysis reveals about Criterion 01
2.5
5
Across the 275 assessed policies, Criterion 01 received an average score of 2.5 out of 5, indicating moderate overall performance and considerable variation across the sample.
How do we achieve our scores?
-
51% of organisations scored 3 or above, demonstrating a meaningful attempt to connect faith identity with investment practice.
-
However, 49% scored 2 or below, revealing substantial room for improvement across the field.
-
Most notably, 29% of organisations scored 0 or 1, meaning their investment policies contained minimal or no faith-specific content
-
A small minority (8%) achieved exemplary integration, demonstrating strong and explicit faith documentation.
Key takeaway: This pattern highlights a central and striking finding of the assessment: Many organisations with strong faith identities do not clearly articulate that identity within their investment policy documents.
One of the most consistent patterns is the 'name without substance' problem – ie, referencing faith identity through the organisation's name, for example, but failing to articulate how faith informs investment decision-making
In such cases, policies often function as largely secular financial instruments, even when drafted by deeply religious institutions.
These insights are taken from FaithInvest's 104-page Good Intentions 2026 study: for the full analysis, including trends in how faith traditions and organisational structures differ, download the Good Intentions report.
What best practice looks like
Strong faith foundation documentation does not require lengthy theological essays. What distinguishes the best policies is clarity, specificity, and relevance – the ability to show, not merely assert, that faith shapes how money is invested. Across every tradition, the strongest documentation consistently contains four building blocks:

-
Faith identity: Explicit identification of the faith tradition informing the policy.
-
Core principles: A clear statement of the core theological or ethical principles appropriate to that tradition.
-
Authoritative grounding: Reference to recognised denominational or authoritative guidance, and to the sacred texts or teachings the principles rest on, where applicable.
-
Translation into practice: A clear explanation of how those faith values translate into investment decision-making, rather than remaining abstract.
The strongest documentation shows how faith commitments shape priorities, boundaries, and responsibilities in practice.
Scroll down to download a best practice template you can adapt for your own organisation's faith-consistent investment policy. Or click below to be taken to the next in the FCI Framework's 10 criteria.
A template you can adapt
The elements above become far easier to apply when set out as a simple template. We have created a best practice framework for each criterion that walks through each building block in turn.
Our best practice templates are available exclusively to faith-based organisations that are members of the FCI Centre. Sign up below to become a member and to receive the template for this criterion alone or for our FCI Framework Best Practice Guide with all ten criteria. Membership of the FCI Centre is currently free.

