
FCI FRAMEWORK
A framework for an effective faith-consistent investing policy and a model for good practice
We believe our FCI Assessment Framework, which we developed as part of our Good Intentions 2026 research, is a game-changer for faith-consistent investors. It provides a clear framework for faith-based asset owners to use as they review their own policies. And to help them further, we have developed a suite of model templates and best practice language for each of the 10 criteria.
How the FCI Framework is structured
Our FCI Framework measures how effectively faith commitments are translated into clear and operational investment guidance. It has ten criteria which cover both policy content and governance structures supporting implementation.
They start with Criterion 01, faith foundation documentation, which we believe is the critical first step to developing a comprehensive faith-consistent investing policy. Other criteria cover ethical exclusions, positive investment, governance arrangements, professional oversight, monitoring processes, mechanisms for policy development, and more.
FCI has traditionally centred on negative screening to exclude activities considered compatible with faith teachings. However, as FCI has gained momentum in recent years, organisations are increasingly seeking to ensure their investments reflect the values and beliefs that guide their wider work.
The FCI Framework gives them a structure to enable them to do so – and we have added guidance on how faith-based organisations can strengthen their investment policies and guidelines, sometimes with quite simple changes to language and procedures. Click below to find out more about each criterion, or to learn now we score the FCI Framework.
What our Good Intentions 2026 study found when we assessed 275 faith investment policies
Our Good Intentions 2026 is the most comprehensive in-depth mapping of the current state of FCI to date.
When we applied our FCI Framework to 275 faith-based policies from a wide range of traditions and regions, we found that 89% of organisations score below 30 out of a possible maximum aggregate score of 50. This means most organisations fall with a 'basic effort' category, remaining at an early stage of FCI. (See how we score each criterion below.)
FCI is an area of practice that is still evolving. But the study also found that the extent to which faiths' values are translated into investment practice is often shaped by access to resources, expertise and supporting infrastructure such as denominational networks. The FCI Framework provides some of the guidance that otherwise they may lack access to.
What each of the 10 criteria sets out to do
Below you will find each of the 10 criteria, with a formal definition of what it measures, taken from our Good Intentions 2026 study, and a comment from the deep dives we held into the Good Intentions research, plus a link to more detailed information about each criterion, including best practice examples.
Criterion 01:
Faith foundation documentation
The extent to which the organisation clearly states how its faith tradition and teachings inform its investment approach.
Criterion 1 asks the simple question: Does your investment policy actually explain that you are a faith organisation and what that means for how you invest?
Criterion 03:
Positive screening & affirmative investment
The extent to which the policy articulates what the organisation
seeks to support through investment, not only what it avoids.
What does your investment policy say you actively want to support, not just what to avoid, but what should your capital be directed towards?
Criterion 04:
Investment vehicle
selection
The extent to which selected investment vehicles are capable of implementing the organisation’s stated faith commitments.
Can the investment funds and managers you are using deliver on your commitments? Because if not, your policy may just be aspirational rather than operational.
Criterion 05:
Governance &
decision-making
The extent to which governance structures ensure that faith values are considered alongside fiduciary responsibility in investment decisions.
When the people responsible for your assets within your organisation sit down to make investment decisions, is faith part of the conversation?
Criterion 06:
Stakeholder communications & accountability
The extent to which the organisation communicats transparently about faith-aligned investment practice and accountability to stakeholders.
This asks whether your community, your congregation, your members, the people that you serve, know how you invest and why.
Criterion 07:
Education & expertise requirements
The extent to which those responsible for investment decisions are equipped to understand and apply faith-consistent investing.
This asks: Do the people responsible for investment decisions actually have the knowledge they need to make faith-consistent investing decisions?
Criterion 08:
Professional
guidance
The extent to which external advisers and managers are explicitly
expected to integrate faith considerations into their professional role.
This asks: If your organisation hires an advisor or a fund manager, how do you make sure that they understand what your faith commitments actually mean in practice?
Criterion 09:
Regular review &
monitoring
The extent to which faith alignment is reviewed and monitored over
time, alongside financial performance.
This is the strongest scoring criterion across the whole study. Faith organisations are disciplined about financial monitoring. But the values check is a different story.
Criterion 10:
Continuous improvement framework
The extent to which faith-consistent investing is treated as an evolving
practice that is reviewed, strengthened, and refined over time.
This is about whether the policy itself is treated as a living document. And what we found is that most policies in our sample were written once and then they're filed away.
How we score the FCI framework criteria
Each criterion is scored on a 0–5 scale, producing an overall composite score out of a maximum possible score of 50 points.
Scores are sequential, meaning that a policy must satisfy all requirements at lower score levels before it can achieve higher ones.
This reflects the understanding that faith-consistent investing capabilities build cumulatively, from clear theological foundations through to more sophisticated governance and accountability frameworks.
-
Score 1 (score range 0-9): No meaningful integration of faith principles into investment guidance
-
Score 2 (score range 10-19): Minimal FCI implementation (limited integration of faith principles into investment guidance)
-
Score 3 (score range 20-29): Basic effort but significant improvements needed (foundational elements present but unevenly developed)
-
Score 4 (score range 30-39): Good foundation with some gaps (solid faith-based approach with identifiable areas for enhancement)
-
Score 5 (score range 40-50): Outstanding FCI alignment (comprehensive integration of faith principles with advanced implementation frameworks)
