top of page
Image by Dmitry Osipenko

FCI FRAMEWORK #08

Professional guidance
FCI Framework Criterion 08

Clarifying the mandate of external expertise

Professional guidance overview

CRITERION 08

Many faith-based asset owners delegate portfolio management to external professionals, which is often necessary given the complexity of financial markets. This criterion considers whether faith alignment is clearly incorporated into those delegated responsibilities.

​

Investment professionals typically operate within frameworks that prioritise risk

management, return optimisation, and regulatory compliance. Unless faith commitments are clearly defined within mandates or advisory agreements, they may remain secondary considerations in portfolio implementation.

​​

Criterion 08 examines whether external advisers and asset managers are explicitly required to implement faith commitments as part of their professional mandate.

​

Why professional guidance matters

As explained above, faith-based organisations often rely heavily on their professional advisors for their investment knowledge and expertise.

 

While managers are generally expected to deliver competitive financial performance, they are not always required to demonstrate expertise in faith-consistent investing. However, without explicit expectations, faith commitments may gradually recede from day-to-day investment decisions, particularly during periods of market pressure. ​

​

For example, proxy voting and corporate engagement are frequently absent. Where mentioned, they are often delegated to managers without instruction to align voting or engagement with faith commitments. 

Common gaps and weaknesses

Across traditions and organisation types, several recurring weaknesses emerge in relation to professional guidance and mandate clarity.

  • No requirement for faith-based expertise: Values are stated but are not necessarily operationalised through capability expectations.

  • Stewardship is underdeveloped or delegated without guidance: Few policies include instructions on proxy voting and corporate engagement, removing the potential to use stewardship as an active tool of mission.

  • No preference for faith-aligned providers: Most organisations do not prioritise managers with faith-based investing experience, even where such options exist.

  • Separation of finance and values: Many policies implicitly divide financial management from ethical oversight. Without integration, alignment becomes reactive rather than embedded.

  • Template-driven policy design: Some policies appear adapted from generic investment templates, with detailed financial provisions but only minimal faith integration.

  • Limited denominational literacy expectations: Even where compliance with denominational guidelines is required, few policies expect advisers to understand the theological foundations behind those guidelines. 

What our analysis reveals about criterion 08

2.5
5

Across the 275 assessed policies, Criterion 08 displays moderate overall performance at 2.5 out of 5, yet the depth of performance is uneven. 

How do we achieve our scores?

​

  • Most organisations (71%) fall within the middle range, scoring 2 or 3, indicating basic to moderate professional guidance.

  • Only 14% demonstrate strong or comprehensive faith-integrated requirements (scores 4–5)

  • 15% provide minimal or no faith-specific professional expectations (scores 0–1).

 

Tthis suggests that most organisations have established some form of professional oversight. However, the middle-range scores may reflect strong fiduciary frameworks rather than genuinely faith-integrated professional mandates. 

 

In practice, many policies:

  • Define advisor qualifications clearly.

  • Establish reporting expectations on financial performance.

 

Fewer specify:

  • Explicit integration of denominational screening frameworks.

  • Proxy voting expectations aligned with theological commitments.

  • Regular reporting on faith-alignment compliance.

 

Key takeaway: 

The apparent strength in this criterion may mask a deeper gap between financial professionalism and theological integration.

investing. Many organisations demonstrate robust financial frameworks yet do not explicitly require investment professionals to understand or implement FCI principles. In other words, professional financial competence is often well defined, whereas faith-specific competence is not.​

​

These insights are taken from FaithInvest's 104-page Good Intentions 2026 study: for the full analysis, including trends in how different traditions and organisational structures differ, download the Good Intentions report.

What best practice looks like

Higher-performing policies typically include:

_edited_edited.png

​

  • Requirement that managers demonstrate experience in faith-consistent investing

  • Explicit compliance verification procedures 

  • Clear proxy voting guidelines

  • Structured stewardship reporting expectations

  • Preference hierarchies for faith-aligned providers

 

Professional guidance frameworks tend to strengthen with institutional scale rather than denominational identity. Denominational investment pools and pension funds demonstrate the most structured expectations for professional expertise and stewardship practices.

​

Scroll down for a best practice template you can adapt for your organisation's investment policy.

Move to the next FCI criterion: No 09

A template you can adapt

The elements above become far easier to apply when set out as a simple template. We have created a best practice framework for each criterion that walks through each building block in turn.

 

Our best practice templates are available exclusively to faith-based organisations that are members of the FCI Centre. Sign up below to become a member and to receive the template for this criterion alone or for our FCI Framework Best Practice Guide with all ten criteria. Membership of the FCI Centre is currently free.

angel statue under blue sky during dayti

JOIN THE FCI CENTRE COMMUNITY

Be the first to know about new resources and events as well as news and developments on faith-consistent investing and the wider FCI ecosystem!

Join our mailing list

We will keep your personal details safe and never share them with any other organisations without your permission or for marketing purposes. Please see the FaithInvest privacy policy which covers how we handle your information and protect your privacy.​ Unsubscribe at any time.

CofE logo-all white2.png

The FCI Centre of Excellence is an initiative of FaithInvest, a UK-based international non-profit founded in 2019 to support faiths to invest in line with their values.​ FaithInvest is a registered charity (no 1187015) and a registered company limited by guarantee (no 11862410). It has been deemed equivalent to a 501(c)(3) public charity in the United States by NGOsource.

FCI: Faith-consistent investing​​

Faith-consistent investing (also known as faith-based or faith-aligned investing) is an investment approach that explicitly aligns financial portfolios with the moral, ethical, and spiritual teachings of a specific religious or faith tradition.

© 2026 by FaithInvest

CONNECT WITH US

  • LinkedIn

ADDRESS

FaithInvest

Stone King LLP

91-93 Charterhouse St

London, EC1M 6HR

UK​​

CONTACT DETAILS

bottom of page