top of page
Image by KOSMAS HIOLOS

FCI FRAMEWORK #09

Regular review and monitoring
FCI Framework Criterion 09

Ensuring alignment over time

Regular review and monitoring overview

CRITERION 09

Regular monitoring is important because investment portfolios change continuously. Holdings evolve, managers adjust strategies, and new risks emerge. Without structured review mechanisms, even well-designed faith-aligned portfolios can gradually drift from their intended values framework.

​

Effective monitoring, therefore, involves more than reviewing financial performance. It requires checking that exclusions are applied, engagement priorities are maintained, and investment decisions continue to reflect the organisation’s faith commitments. 

​

This criterion considers whether organisations have structured processes to verify that ethical guidelines and policy commitments are applied in practice over time, rather than relying solely on statements in policy documents.

Criterion 09 examines whether faith-based asset owners regularly review and monitor their investments to ensure they remain aligned with both financial objectives and faith commitments.

​​

Why regular review and monitoring matters

As explained above, faith-based organisations often rely heavily on their professional advisors for their investment knowledge and expertise.

 

While managers are generally expected to deliver competitive financial performance, they are not always required to demonstrate expertise in faith-consistent investing. However, without explicit expectations, faith commitments may gradually recede from day-to-day investment decisions, particularly during periods of market pressure. ​

​

For example, proxy voting and corporate engagement are frequently absent. Where mentioned, they are often delegated to managers without instruction to align voting or engagement with faith commitments. 

Common gaps and weaknesses

​The values-monitoring void: The most pervasive weakness is the absence of systematic monitoring of faith alignment. 

  • Lack of integrated assessment: True integration, that is, reviewing financial performance and faith alignment within a single, structured process, remains rare. 

  • Limited stakeholder involvement in review processes: Review and monitoring typically remain internal exercises conducted by committees and advisers. Few organisations provide opportunities for stakeholder or denominational input.

  • Minimal real-time compliance systems: Most monitoring relies on quarterly or annual reviews. Real-time systems that flag potential screening or compliance breaches as they occur are exceptionally uncommon

What our analysis reveals about criterion 09

3.1
5

Across the 275 assessed policies, Criterion 09 recorded the highest average score across the FCI Framework, at 3.1 out of 5 points. 

How do we achieve our scores?

​

  • 81% of organisations scored 3 or above, with 45% concentrated at Score 3 (moderate integrated review) and 35% achieving Score 4 (strong integrated review).

  • Only 3% had minimal review processes in place.

  • 1% achieved the highest Score 5 (comprehensive, real-time monitoring).

 

Financial monitoring is well embedded across faith-based institutions but while financial oversight is strong, assessment frequently noted the absence of:​

  • Systematic verification of exclusion compliance

  • Reporting on faith-aligned positive allocations

  • Formal review of stewardship effectiveness

  • Documented procedures for values breaches

  • Integrated financial and faith dashboards

 

Key takeaway: 

This is the strongest-performing criterion but strength is uneven. ​In many cases, faith criteria were articulated in policy but not embedded into monitoring systems. Faith organisations therefore know whether portfolios meet return targets. Fewer know whether portfolios remain consistently aligned with stated faith commitments.

​

These insights are taken from FaithInvest's 104-page Good Intentions 2026 study: for the full analysis, including trends in how different traditions and organisational structures differ, download the Good Intentions report.

What best practice looks like

Higher-performing policies share several characteristics:

_edited_edited.png

​

  • Values compliance incorporated into quarterly reviews

  • Third-party screening verification

  • Dedicated oversight committees for social responsibility

  • Clear protocols for responding to breaches

  • Integrated reporting on financial and faith performance

  • Periodic reassessment of denominational guidance

 

The distinguishing feature is integration. Faith review is not an afterthought. It is embedded within governance cycles.

​

Scroll down for a best practice template you can adapt for your organisation's investment policy.

Move to the next FCI criterion: No 10

A template you can adapt

The elements above become far easier to apply when set out as a simple template. We have created a best practice framework for each criterion that walks through each building block in turn.

 

Our best practice templates are available exclusively to faith-based organisations that are members of the FCI Centre. Sign up below to become a member and to receive the template for this criterion alone or for our FCI Framework Best Practice Guide with all ten criteria. Membership of the FCI Centre is currently free.

angel statue under blue sky during dayti

JOIN THE FCI CENTRE COMMUNITY

Be the first to know about new resources and events as well as news and developments on faith-consistent investing and the wider FCI ecosystem!

Join our mailing list

We will keep your personal details safe and never share them with any other organisations without your permission or for marketing purposes. Please see the FaithInvest privacy policy which covers how we handle your information and protect your privacy.​ Unsubscribe at any time.

CofE logo-all white2.png

The FCI Centre of Excellence is an initiative of FaithInvest, a UK-based international non-profit founded in 2019 to support faiths to invest in line with their values.​ FaithInvest is a registered charity (no 1187015) and a registered company limited by guarantee (no 11862410). It has been deemed equivalent to a 501(c)(3) public charity in the United States by NGOsource.

FCI: Faith-consistent investing​​

Faith-consistent investing (also known as faith-based or faith-aligned investing) is an investment approach that explicitly aligns financial portfolios with the moral, ethical, and spiritual teachings of a specific religious or faith tradition.

© 2026 by FaithInvest

CONNECT WITH US

  • LinkedIn

ADDRESS

FaithInvest

Stone King LLP

91-93 Charterhouse St

London, EC1M 6HR

UK​​

CONTACT DETAILS

bottom of page