top of page
Image by chris robert

FCI FRAMEWORK #02

Ethical exclusions and negative screening
FCI Framework criterion 02

Setting faith-based limits on what is investable

CRITERION 02

Ethical exclusions and negative screening overview

Negative screening is the most established expression of faith-consistent investing, reflecting the long-standing belief that ownership carries moral responsibility and that investment policies should set clear ethical boundaries. That's particularly the case among denominational investment bodies and pension funds, where exclusion frameworks are often clearly defined and operationalised.

​

Negative screening matters because it signals that financial returns are not morally neutral and that some forms of profit are incompatible with faith commitments. Clear exclusions are widely understood by stakeholders, support transparency, and are generally recognised within fiduciary practice when consistently applied.

​

However, screening primarily defines what an organisation will not support. While it establishes an important ethical foundation, it does not by itself determine how capital is directed toward mission-aligned purposes.

For Criterion 02, the assessment examines whether a faith-based organisation clearly identifies industries, activities, or corporate behaviours that are excluded from investment on the basis of faith principles, and whether these exclusions are defined and applied in a consistent, operational way.

​

Why faith-based exclusions matter 

  • Primary point of implementation: Negative screening is often the main way faith commitments are translated into portfolio construction and oversight.

  • Reduces interpretation risk: Vague or incomplete screening frameworks force advisers and managers to infer intent, increasing the risk of inconsistency and misalignment over time.

  • Provides mandate clarity: Clearly documented exclusions, revenue thresholds, and asset-class coverage give professionals a shared reference point.

  • Enables consistent delivery and accountability: Strong frameworks support reliable implementation, compliance monitoring, and transparent reporting to trustees and stakeholders.

Common gaps and weaknesses

  • Absence of any exclusions: 29% of organisations have no exclusionary language at all

  • Vague or symbolic screening: For example, using language such as 'conflict with values' without providing defined categories

  • Lack of implementation guidance

  • Partial coverage across asset classes creating inconsistency

What our analysis reveals about criterion 02

2.1
5

Across the 275 assessed policies, Criterion 02 received an average score of 2.1 out of 5, revealing a surprising gap, given that negative screening is the oldest and most basic form of faith-based investing. 

How do we achieve our scores?

​

  • 29% of organisations include no exclusionary language whatsoever in their investment policies.

  • 22% have minimal or basic screening.

  • 51% score 3 or above, indicating that where organisations commit to negative screening, many develop clear and relatively sophisticated frameworks.

  • But of these, a meagre 8% demonstrate comprehensive exclusionary screening

​

Key takeaway: This pattern is striking given the long history of exclusionary investing across faith traditions. The central insight is the uneven translation of long-standing faith practice into formal, operational investment policy.

​

These insights are taken from FaithInvest's 104-page Good Intentions 2026 study: for the full analysis, including trends in how different traditions and organisational structures differ, download the Good Intentions report.

What best practice looks like

Higher-scoring policies demonstrate that effective negative screening is not defined by exhaustive exclusion lists, but by clarity, consistency, and implementability. The strongest frameworks move beyond faith aspiration and provide operational instruction that allows exclusions to be applied consistently and verified in practice. ​

_edited_edited.png

Where screening is done well, common features include:

​

  • Clearly defined exclusion categories explicitly linked to faith teachings

  • Revenue thresholds that balance moral clarity with investment practicality​​

  • Clear guidance for investment managers on screening tools, monitoring, compliance

  • Application of exclusions across asset classes, not only public equities

  • Periodic review processes to ensure continued relevance as social and economic conditions evolve.

 

Strong practice is evident among organisations that connect theological clarity with operational detail at a smaller scale.

​

Scroll down to download a best practice template you can adapt for your own organisation's faith-consistent investment policy. Or click below to be taken to the next in the FCI Framework's 10 criteria.

Click to move to the next FCI Assessment criterion: No 03

A template you can adapt

The elements above become far easier to apply when set out as a simple template. We have created a best practice framework for each criterion that walks through each building block in turn.

 

Our best practice templates are available exclusively to faith-based organisations that are members of the FCI Centre. Sign up below to become a member and to receive the template for this criterion alone or for our FCI Framework Best Practice Guide with all ten criteria. Membership of the FCI Centre is currently free.

​​

angel statue under blue sky during dayti

JOIN THE FCI CENTRE COMMUNITY

Be the first to know about new resources and events as well as news and developments on faith-consistent investing and the wider FCI ecosystem!

Join our mailing list

We will keep your personal details safe and never share them with any other organisations without your permission or for marketing purposes. Please see the FaithInvest privacy policy which covers how we handle your information and protect your privacy.​ Unsubscribe at any time.

CofE logo-all white2.png

The FCI Centre of Excellence is an initiative of FaithInvest, a UK-based international non-profit founded in 2019 to support faiths to invest in line with their values.​ FaithInvest is a registered charity (no 1187015) and a registered company limited by guarantee (no 11862410). It has been deemed equivalent to a 501(c)(3) public charity in the United States by NGOsource.

FCI: Faith-consistent investing​​

Faith-consistent investing (also known as faith-based or faith-aligned investing) is an investment approach that explicitly aligns financial portfolios with the moral, ethical, and spiritual teachings of a specific religious or faith tradition.

© 2026 by FaithInvest

CONNECT WITH US

  • LinkedIn

ADDRESS

FaithInvest

Stone King LLP

91-93 Charterhouse St

London, EC1M 6HR

UK​​

CONTACT DETAILS

bottom of page