
FCI FRAMEWORK #03
Positive screening and affirmative investment
FCI Framework criterion 03
Directing capital towards faith-aligned outcomes
Positive screening & affirmative investment overview
CRITERION 03
Positive screening and affirmative investment reflect the constructive dimension of faith-consistent investing. Across religious traditions, we find an emphasis on promoting values such as the pursuit of justice, care for creation, and the promotion of the common good.
By identifying mission-aligned investment priorities, organisations can more clearly connect their financial resources with their wider social and ministry objectives, supporting areas such as community development, environmental solutions, or other activities consistent with their faith commitments.
Faith-based organisations consistently tell us that they want to their investments to be directed towards initiatives that seek to achieve positive good. However, our Good Intentions 2026 study found that their investment policies do not reflect this aspiration – this criterion received the lowest score across the dataset.
Criterion 03 examines whether investment policies move beyond avoiding harm to actively seeking investments that advance faith-based values and mission-aligned outcomes. Do organisations explain what they seek to support through their investments, and is this translated into practical investment guidance?
Why clear positive screening statements matter
-
High relevance for advisers and managers: Without articulated positive priorities, implementation defaults to generic ESG frameworks or purely financial optimisation
-
Risk of missed alignment: The absence of clear positive direction limits the ability to authentically align portfolios with faith objectives
-
Lost opportunity for long-term impact: Without guidance, advisers may overlook investment approaches that support long-term systemic resilience and mission outcomes.
Common gaps and weaknesses
-
Exclusion-only approaches: Many organisations have developed detailed negative screening frameworks but include no affirmative investment criteria at all. Policies are clear about what to avoid, but silent on what their capital should actively support.
-
Aspirational language without substance: Some policies acknowledge the potential for positive investment or values alignment, but provide no criteria, guidance, or allocation intent. Without operational direction, positive screening remains symbolic.
-
Failure to translate denominational priorities: Despite rich theological resources across traditions, most policies do not operationalise faith-specific priorities (eg, human dignity, social justice, tikkun olam) into concrete investment themes.
-
No measurement or learning mechanisms: Very few organisations set expectations for tracking outcomes or reviewing whether positive investments advance mission goals. Dedicated allocations to community development or impact investing are rare.
What our analysis reveals about criterion 03
1.6
5
Across the 275 assessed policies, Criterion 03 recorded the lowest average score in the entire framework, at 1.6 out of a total of 5, indicating that positive screening remains significantly underdeveloped relative to other dimensions of faith-consistent investing.
-
28% of organisations scored 0 and 23% scored 1, meaning that more than half of faith-based policies assessed have no or minimal positive investment provisions. These policies approach investment purely as financial optimisation with exclusions.
-
Only 15% of organisations scored 3 to achieved even a moderate threshold. The weakness at the moderate levels, or what can be regarded as the missing middle, shows the field has not developed a robust middle tier of positive screening practice.
-
Only 11% of organisations scored 4 or above, demonstrating that robust affirmative investment practice remains rare.
Key takeaway: Positive screening remains the least developed element of faith-consistent investing, reflecting that faith organisations tend to place a much greater focus on avoidance rather than proactive alignment.
This is a translation gap, not a faith gap: Across traditions, rich theological resources for affirmative investment exist, but these commitments are rarely translated into clear, operational policy guidance.
These insights are taken from FaithInvest's 104-page Good Intentions 2026 study: for the full analysis, including trends in how different traditions and organisational structures differ, download the Good Intentions report.

What best practice looks like
Higher-scoring policies demonstrate that positive screening requires intentionality and clarity. Strong practice typically builds on existing foundations such as ESG language or mission statements, and translates them into concrete, faith-aligned investment direction. Common features of effective positive screening include:
-
Explicit identification of faith-aligned positive priorities, often beginning with broad ESG considerations and refining them through faith-specific values.
-
Clear connection between mission, theology, and investment themes, moving beyond generic references to 'values' or 'charitable purpose' to explain what the organisation seeks to support through its capital.
-
Use of denominational or faith-aligned investment vehicles, enabling organisations to access established positive screening frameworks even where internal capacity is limited.
-
Modest but intentional allocations to impact, community, or mission-aligned investments, signalling commitment without requiring wholesale portfolio redesign.
-
Basic expectations for monitoring or reporting positive outcomes, supporting accountability even where formal impact measurement is still developing.
Scroll down to download a best practice template you can adapt for your own organisation's faith-consistent investment policy. Or click below to be taken to the next in the FCI Framework's 10 criteria.
A template you can adapt
The elements above become far easier to apply when set out as a simple template. We have created a best practice framework for each criterion that walks through each building block in turn.
Our best practice templates are available exclusively to faith-based organisations that are members of the FCI Centre. Sign up below to become a member and to receive the template for this criterion alone or for our FCI Framework Best Practice Guide with all ten criteria. Membership of the FCI Centre is currently free.

