
FCI FRAMEWORK #04
Investment vehicle selection
FCI Framework Criterion 04
Ensuring faith commitments are implementable
Investment vehicle selection overview
CRITERION 04
The decisions made by faith-based asset owners over which investment vehicles to use are important because policy commitments only shape portfolio outcomes if the chosen vehicles can deliver them.
Organisations may define clear exclusions or express interest in mission-aligned investments, but these commitments remain aspirational if investments are made primarily through broad market funds or managers without the ability to apply faith-based criteria.
Different vehicle types offer varying levels of flexibility, and without careful selection, faith commitments risk weakening at the point where policies are implemented in actual investment portfolios.
.
Criterion 04 assesses whether the investment vehicles selected can reflect the commitments outlined in faiths' policies. It considers whether the funds, managers, or pooled vehicles used are capable of applying the exclusions, positive investment priorities, and stewardship expectations described in the investment framework.
Why investment vehicle selection matters
For advisers and managers, vehicle selection is often treated as a financial optimisation exercise focused on performance; fees; track record; risk metrics; and asset allocation fit.
However, for faith-based clients, it is equally important that the investment products they use can actually deliver their stated faith commitments. Clear vehicle selection guidance:
-
Reduces mandate ambiguity
-
Ensures due diligence considers values alignment
-
Helps ensure pooled products can support, rather than weaken, stated faith commitments
Without explicit vehicle selection criteria, advisers may default to conventional products that undermine stated faith objectives.
Common gaps and weaknesses
-
No clear vehicle preference: Most organisations do not prioritise denominational or faith-based investment vehicles over conventional options, treating all products as functionally equivalent.
-
Financial due diligence without values criteria: Policies typically contain detailed performance and risk requirements, but provide no criteria for assessing whether a vehicle can implement faith-based exclusions or positive priorities.
-
No verification of implementation capability: Few organisations require confirmation that selected vehicles can actually deliver stated screening criteria.
-
Limited ability to address pooled fund limitations: Where screening is difficult in commingled vehicles and while some policies accept these constraints, few articulate strategies to mitigate them or explore alternative aligned options.
Findings suggest that improving faith-consistent investment outcomes is not solely the responsibility of individual organisations. There is a broader need to strengthen the
ecosystem of available investment vehicles. This includes expanding the availability of faith-aligned products, and supporting collaboration across faith-based asset owners to aggregate demand and influence product development.
What our analysis reveals about criterion 03
2.0
5
Across the 275 assessed policies, Criterion 04 recorded an average score of 2.0 out of 5, indicating weak to moderate integration overall.
-
No organisation achieved the highest score level.
-
35% scored 0–1, indicating little or no values consideration in vehicle selection
-
78% clustered between scores 1–3, suggesting that for most faith organisations, vehicle selection is predominantly treated as a financial process with limited faith integration.
The dominant pattern across the dataset is striking: Many organisations express clear faith principles and detailed exclusion policies yet rely on investment vehicle selection frameworks driven primarily by financial criteria, without demonstrating that those vehicles can implement their stated values in practice.
Interpretation note: Lower scores in investment vehicle selection do not always reflect weak intent. In many cases, organisations face structural constraints, including centralised pooled investment structures, limited availability of faith-aligned products, reliance on external advisors, and scale-related access barriers.
As a result, gaps between policy and implementation may reflect limitations in the wider investment ecosystem rather than organisational commitment. This underscores the need for expanded faith-aligned investment options and stronger collaboration between asset owners, advisors, and managers.
These insights are taken from FaithInvest's 104-page Good Intentions 2026 study: for the full analysis, including trends in how different traditions and organisational structures differ, download the Good Intentions report.

What best practice looks like
Higher-scoring policies demonstrate that effective vehicle selection does not necessarily require complexity, but instead clarity and intentionality. Strong practice typically includes:
-
Explicit preference hierarchies (denominational vehicles first, then faith-based managers, then ESG vehicles, then conventional vehicles where necessary)
-
Values-alignment included as a formal due diligence criterion alongside performance and fees
-
Clear requirement that selected vehicles must be capable of implementing stated exclusions
-
Recognition of asset-class limitations, with structured mitigation strategies
-
Periodic review of available faith-aligned options
Scroll down to download a best practice template you can adapt for your own organisation's faith-consistent investment policy. Or click below to be taken to the next in the FCI Framework's 10 criteria.
A template you can adapt
The elements above become far easier to apply when set out as a simple template. We have created a best practice framework for each criterion that walks through each building block in turn.
Our best practice templates are available exclusively to faith-based organisations that are members of the FCI Centre. Sign up below to become a member and to receive the template for this criterion alone or for our FCI Framework Best Practice Guide with all ten criteria. Membership of the FCI Centre is currently free.

