
FCI FRAMEWORK #05
Governance & decision-making
FCI Framework Criterion 05
Embedding faith within investment oversight
Governance & decision-making overview
CRITERION 05
Earlier criteria assess how faith commitments are expressed in policy; this
criterion considers whether those commitments are reflected in the processes and decision-making structures that guide investment activity. Governance therefore plays a central role in translating policy into practice.
Faith-based organisations often have well-established financial governance systems, including boards, investment committees, and regular reporting processes. However, strong financial oversight does not always mean that faith commitments are actively considered in investment decisions.
Committees may review performance, asset allocation, or manager selection without explicitly assessing whether portfolios reflect denominational teaching or ethical priorities. Where faith integration is absent, investment governance can gradually default to conventional financial decision-making rather than supporting the organisation’s mission and values.
Criterion 05 examines whether the governance structures responsible for investment oversight are designed to ensure that faith principles are considered alongside fiduciary responsibilities this translated into practical investment guidance.
Why governance and decision-making matter
Faith-consistent investing calls for governance processes that embody theological commitments alongside financial responsibility. When governance integrates both, faith identity becomes embedded not only in policy, but in practice.
Clear faith-integrated governance:
-
Provides mandate clarity
-
Reduces interpretation risk
-
Enables dialogue about how faith commitments should be reflected in investment decisions
-
Strengthens long-term faith alignment across leadership changes
Conversely, where governance structures are silent on faith integration, advisers may default to conventional fiduciary models. This can unintentionally marginalise values considerations through omission.
Common gaps and weaknesses
Despite strong overall scores, several gaps were consistently observed:
-
No requirement for faith-consistent investing knowledge among committee members
-
Absence of theological consultation mechanisms
-
No structured values-alignment verification
-
Reliance on denominational identity without operational integration
-
Governance focused exclusively on financial metrics
Committee members are typically appointed for their financial expertise rather than their theological perspective. As a result, discussions tend to focus on risk and return, while faith considerations remain assumed rather than actively examined.
What our analysis reveals about criterion 05
2.9
5
Across the 275 assessed policies, Criterion 05 recorded the second highest average score across the ten criteria at 2.9 out of 5.
-
Nearly three-quarters of organisations (71%) scored 3 or above (achieving moderate, strong or outstanding governance with faith integration).
At first glance, this suggests strong performance across the ecosystem. However, closer analysis reveals a more nuanced picture.
Many organisations received credit for faith integration because they operate within a denominational governance structure. For example:
-
A Catholic diocese governed by a Bishop and Finance Council
-
A Presbyterian church under Session oversight
-
An Episcopal parish governed by a Vestry
While these structures are faith-based in identity, this does not mean that faith principles are actively considered in investment decisions. In numerous cases, governance descriptions focused exclusively on fiduciary duties, financial reporting, and oversight processes, with no explanation of how faith commitments are integrated into deliberations.
Key takeaway:
Governance is one of the strongest-performing area of faith-consistent investing but the strength of this performance is uneven. Many organisations demonstrate sophisticated fiduciary structures without equivalent faith integration. The structure is religious but the process is largely secular.
These insights are taken from FaithInvest's 104-page Good Intentions 2026 study: for the full analysis, including trends in how different traditions and organisational structures differ, download the Good Intentions report.

What best practice looks like
Higher-scoring policies share several characteristics:
-
Explicit articulation of how faith principles inform governance
-
Inclusion of clergy or faith-informed voices in oversight
-
Dedicated social responsibility or values committees
-
Formal linkage between denominational teaching and decision-making
-
Integration of values-alignment review alongside financial monitoring
-
Clear escalation procedures for ethical conflicts
Scroll down to download a best practice template you can adapt for your own organisation's faith-consistent investment policy. Or click below to be taken to the next in the FCI Framework's 10 criteria.
A template you can adapt
The elements above become far easier to apply when set out as a simple template. We have created a best practice framework for each criterion that walks through each building block in turn.
Our best practice templates are available exclusively to faith-based organisations that are members of the FCI Centre. Sign up below to become a member and to receive the template for this criterion alone or for our FCI Framework Best Practice Guide with all ten criteria. Membership of the FCI Centre is currently free.

