
FCI FRAMEWORK: #06
Stakeholder communication
FCI Framework Criterion 06
And the visibility of faith-consistent investing
Stakeholder communication overview
CRITERION 06
This criterion moves beyond internal governance (the subject of Criterion 05) to consider whether faith-consistent investing is explained and made visible to the wider community.
For faith-based organisations, assets are typically held in trust for congregations, donors, beneficiaries, and future generations. Clear communication helps these stakeholders understand how investment decisions reflect shared values and mission priorities. Where communication is limited, it is difficult for communities to assess whether investments align with faith commitments, and opportunities for learning and accountability are reduced.
Across the assessment, many organisations appear to undertake responsible investment activities, but these efforts are not always clearly communicated beyond internal governance structures.
Criterion 06 examines how
faith-based asset owners communicate their investment practices and how these relate to their faith commitments. This includes transparency and opportunities for stakeholders to understand how financial assets are managed in ways consistent with organisational values.
Why stakeholder communication matters
Communication is a matter of accountability, not marketing. Faith-consistent investing is an expression of communal responsibility. Transparency, dialogue, and public reporting strengthen integrity and reinforce the connection between mission and money.
When reporting focuses only on financial performance:
-
Screening and engagement activity remain a mystery
-
Faith-alignment activity has no documented evidence trail to share
-
Stakeholder questions about faith consistency cannot be answered with confidence
-
Opportunities to demonstrate mission-aligned investment leadership are missed
Communication practices tend to follow organisational hierarchy rather than communal identity. Reporting flows upward to boards, bishops, finance councils, trustees, etc, rarely outward to congregations, beneficiaries, or the wider public. As a result, values-alignment work remains unseen by the wider community.
Common gaps and weaknesses
-
The values communication void: Many organisations apply screening frameworks and undertake shareholder engagement in practice, but do not communicate these activities to the wider community.
-
Missing educational initiatives: Most policies contain no provision for educating stakeholders about FCI. As a result, their communities may not understand how faith commitments shape investment decisions.
-
Absence of feedback mechanisms: Very few organisations provide structured opportunities for stakeholder input on investment values to enable evolving theological reflection or community priorities.
-
One-way communication culture: Usually limited to reports or summaries of financial and, occasionally, values-related activity; rarely includes opportunities for questions or discussion.
What our analysis reveals about criterion 06
2.2
5
Across the 275 assessed policies, Criterion 05 received average score across the ten criteria at 2.2 out of 5.
-
Two-thirds of organisations (68%) scored 2 or below, meaning that their stakeholder communication framework was assessed as being basic (51%); minimal (14%); or none (2%).
-
Only one achieved the top score of 5, meaning they had a comprehensive stakeholder communication framework.
-
Results suggest that while financial reporting is widespread, values reporting is not.
Most organisations maintain robust governance reporting structures; quarterly performance summaries, annual financial statements, committee reports. However, these overwhelmingly focus on returns, asset allocation, and benchmark performance.
Organisations rarely report on how investments align with faith commitments or communicate their work to the wider community, which means their values-aligned work remains unseen. Only 3% integrate systematic reporting on:
-
Exclusion compliance
-
Positive investment allocations
-
Investment stewardship outcomes
-
Proxy voting activity
-
Engagement initiatives
Key takeaway: Financial reporting is strong; values reporting is weak. This reflects a recurring theme: FCI is implemented as a technical governance process rather than a shared institutional narrative.
These insights are taken from FaithInvest's 104-page Good Intentions 2026 study: for the full analysis, including trends in how different traditions and organisational structures differ, download the Good Intentions report.
What best practice looks like
Higher-scoring policies share several characteristics:
-
Integrated financial and faith-based reporting
-
Accessible summaries for non-specialist audiences
-
Public availability of policies and guidelines
-
Structured opportunities for stakeholder input
-
Educational initiatives connecting faith teaching to investment practice

Website transparency was one of the clearest differences between higher- and lower-scoring organisations. Higher-performing institutions did not rely solely on internal reports to boards or committees. Instead, they made information publicly accessible by posting performance summaries and explanations of their faith-based investment approach on their websites.
Overall, communication systems for financial oversight are well developed. The gap lies less in reporting structures than in the breadth and depth of values-based communication.
Scroll down to download a best practice template you can adapt for your own organisation's faith-consistent investment policy. Or click below to be taken to the next in the FCI Framework's 10 criteria.
A template you can adapt
The elements above become far easier to apply when set out as a simple template. We have created a best practice framework for each criterion that walks through each building block in turn.
Our best practice templates are available exclusively to faith-based organisations that are members of the FCI Centre. Sign up below to become a member and to receive the template for this criterion alone or for our FCI Framework Best Practice Guide with all ten criteria. Membership of the FCI Centre is currently free.

