
FCI FRAMEWORK #07
Education and expertise
FCI Framework Criterion 07
Forming the stewards of faith-based capital
Education and expertise overview
CRITERION 07
Faith traditions contain extensive ethical reflection on economic life, justice, stewardship, and responsibility. However, applying these principles within investment portfolios requires specialised understanding of financial tools and responsible investment practices.
This criterion considers whether trustees and investment committees are equipped to translate documented faith commitments into informed decision-making within real financial markets.
Without access to appropriate expertise or training, investment committees may rely heavily on external advisers for interpretation. While professional advice is valuable, this can shift the practical interpretation of faith commitments away from the faith community and toward financial intermediaries.
Criterion 07 examines whether those responsible for investment oversight – eg, trustees and investment committee members – have the knowledge and support needed to interpret and apply faith-consistent investing in practice.
Why education and expertise matter
Faith-consistent investing calls for dual levels of expertise and understanding. As well as the required financial literacy and understanding of investment tools and practices, those appointed as trustees or investment committee members also need to consider how their organisation's ethical frameworks and principles should guide investment decisions.
Yet the assessment shows that across faith traditions, organisations expect financial oversight competence but rarely require trustees or ethical investment committee members to understand ethical frameworks in depth, and do not embed FCI education within governance cycles.
This leaves a question mark over whether trustees and investment committee members are expected to oversee faith alignment without being equipped to interpret it.
Common gaps and weaknesses
-
The universal education gap: Most policies contain no expectations for trustee formation, denominational literacy, or ongoing professional development in values-based investing.
-
No theological literacy expectations: Few policies require committee members to understand their own tradition’s investment guidance or ethical framework.
-
Missing network engagement and continuing formation: Participation in denominational investor networks, conferences, or collaborative learning platforms is almost never required.
-
Structural and cultural causes: For example, the assumption that shared faith identity equates to investment literacy; the tendency to treat investment as a purely technical function; reliance on generic policy templates; and limited awareness of available denominational education resources.
What our analysis reveals about criterion 07
1.4
5
Across the 275 assessed policies, Criterion 07 recorded the lowest average score across the ten criteria at 1.4 out of 5.
-
More than half of organisations include no structured education requirement beyond generic fiduciary language.
-
Even where professional development is mentioned, it typically refers to financial literacy rather than faith-consistent investing expertise.
-
The data suggests that education is not yet viewed as a formal governance responsibility within most traditions.
The absence of explicit formation requirements may reflect the historical development of investment governance. Financial oversight frameworks matured over decades within regulatory and fiduciary systems. Faith-consistent investing, by contrast, is comparatively recent as a formalised discipline.
Key takeaway:
Education is the weakest dimension of faith-consistent investing. With the lowest average score of all ten criteria, the vast majority of organisations provide little or no structured formation for those overseeing faith-aligned investments. The gap is universal across traditions: Education deficiencies appear across Catholic, Protestant, Anglican, and Jewish institutions alike. No tradition has meaningfully solved the formation challenge.
These insights are taken from FaithInvest's 104-page Good Intentions 2026 study: for the full analysis, including trends in how different traditions and organisational structures differ, download the Good Intentions report.
What best practice looks like
Stronger-performing organisations demonstrates intentionality. They may provide:

-
Structured orientation sessions for new trustees
-
Required review of denominational investment guidance
-
Participation in faith-based investor networks
-
Periodic consultation with theological advisers
-
Ongoing discussion of evolving ethical questions
The common feature is an acknowledgement that faith-consistent investing requires informed discernment. Education strengthens confidence and it enables committees to interrogate adviser recommendations constructively rather than defer reflexively.
Scroll down for a best practice template you can adapt for your organisation's investment policy.
A template you can adapt
The elements above become far easier to apply when set out as a simple template. We have created a best practice framework for each criterion that walks through each building block in turn.
Our best practice templates are available exclusively to faith-based organisations that are members of the FCI Centre. Sign up below to become a member and to receive the template for this criterion alone or for our FCI Framework Best Practice Guide with all ten criteria. Membership of the FCI Centre is currently free.

